So she's a woman.
That doesn't mean I've got to vote for her.
Not when she supports homosexual marriage and universally bad healthcare, all the while touting her "femininity."
So he's a Christian.
That doesn't mean I've got to vote for him.
Not when he's for bigger government, is on the opposite side of the immigration question from me, and touts his faith.
If it's clear in example (A), then isn't it clear in example (B)?